Pantsers vs. Plotters

Pantsers vs. Plotters: The Ultimate Showdown

In the blue corner, wearing loose-fitting jeans that look suspiciously like they were put on in a hurry (because they were), we have the Pantsers. And in the red corner, with meticulously pressed trousers that have more lines than a Shakespeare play, stand the Plotters. Welcome to the ultimate showdown in the writing world: Pantsers vs. Plotters.

Round 1: Preparation

Plotters come to the ring with a battle plan. They’ve got outlines, character arcs, and plot points so well-defined that if you squint, their notebooks look like they contain the blueprints to a very confusing, highly emotional building. They’ve researched everything from the average rainfall in medieval France to the tensile strength of spider silk, just in case.

Pantsers, on the other hand, show up with a coffee-stained napkin with “write something cool” scribbled on it. Their preparation involves ensuring their playlist has enough epic tracks to score their unforeseen literary journey and maybe, just maybe, deciding on a protagonist’s name. Plot? They’ll figure it out as they go.

Round Winner: It’s a tie. Plotters win for organization, but Pantsers earn equal points for optimism and bravery.

Round 2: Writing Process

Plotters proceed with the precision of a Swiss watch. Each chapter is written according to plan, and deviations are as welcome as a skunk at a garden party. The plotter’s path is like a well-tended garden; everything grows exactly where it’s supposed to.

Pantsers embark on a literary joyride, taking every side road and scenic route that catches their fancy. Characters appear out of nowhere, demanding to be part of the story, and plot twists are decided by the flip of a coin or the outcome of a basketball game. Their story’s path resembles a child’s scribble, but somehow, they end up at the right destination.

Round Winner: Pantsers, for sheer entertainment value and keeping the spirit of adventure alive.

Round 3: Revising

Plotters enter the revision stage with a checklist. They adjust a dialogue here, tighten a scene there, and occasionally mourn the loss of a subplot that looked much better in the outline. It’s like fine-tuning a machine where all parts must work in perfect harmony.

Pantsers look at their first draft and wonder if it was written by them or by a group of monkeys on a typewriter. The revision process involves major surgery, a lot of head-scratching, and occasional moments of brilliance where they can’t believe they wrote something so clever (or so they think at 3 AM).

Round Winner: Plotters, for saving themselves from a mountain of existential dread and caffeine overdoses.

Final Round: Crossing the Finish Line

Plotters cross the finish line with a manuscript that’s polished, coherent, and closely resembles their original vision. They’ve navigated the treacherous waters of storytelling with a map and compass, reaching their destination as planned.

Pantsers stumble across the finish line with a manuscript that’s wild, unpredictable, and utterly unique. They’ve ridden the waves of creativity without a map, discovering uncharted territories along the way.

Final Verdict: It’s a draw! In the world of writing, whether you’re a Pantser or a Plotter, the victory lies in the stories we tell and the worlds we create. So, whether you meticulously plan your narrative or make it up as you go along, remember: the pen is mightier than the sword (but a keyboard is preferable, less chance of ink stains).

The ultimate showdown between Pantsers and Plotters ends in a celebration of diversity in creativity. So, pick your side (or don’t), and let the words flow!

Thank you for signing up!